Global Service-Learning

Wikis > GSL Wiki > GSL Research > Global Service-Learning

Significant research has been central to the development of best practices in global service-learning. We list these pieces immediately below and offer article abstracts farther down the page. Every effort is made to list the abstracts in the same order as the pieces are listed above (generally by most recent publication). The list developed here is listed chronologically in reverse-order, to show the conceptual development and research foundation in this growing field. We kindly request that any individuals interested in adding to this wiki do so by following the guidelines we have established.

Peer Reviewed Articles:

Books:

Chapters:

 

Dissertations, Theses, and Other Works:

 

Websites:

 

Article Abstracts:

Crabtree, R. (2008). Theoretical foundations for international service-learning. Michigan Journal of Community Service, 15(1), 18-36.

International service-learning (ISL) combines academic instruction and community-based service in an international context. Objectives of linking international travel, education, and community service include increasing participants’ global awareness, building intercultural understanding, and enhancing civic mindedness and skills. Research on cross-cultural adjustment, approaches to community development, models of democratic research, and a variety of pedagogical theories are discussed as foundations upon which we can better understand the intellectual and political context for ISL and the student learning it makes possible. These literatures also provide frameworks for creating ethical ISL experiences that positively impact the communities and developing countries where we work and can inform project assessment and critique, as well as future research.

 

Hatcher, J.A. & Erasmus, M.A. (2008). Service-learning in the United States and South Africa: A comparative analysis informed by John Dewey and Julius Nyerere. Michigan Journal of Community Service Learning, 15(1), 49-61.

As the prevalence of service-learning within higher education institutions grows across the globe there is value to explore, discuss, and describe the similarities and differences between the various expressions that are emerging. Such comparative analysis can deepen understanding of service-learning pedagogy, improve practice, and create a framework for future research. This paper compares service-learning in the United States and South Africa to understand Western-oriented and Africanized expressions of this promising teaching strategy. The analysis identifies three dimensions derived from the educational theories of John Dewey and Julius Nyerere and finds there is mutual agreement as to the value of developing civic-minded graduates. However, in the U.S., service-learning is supported primarily by nonprofit associations and stakeholders within higher education, whereas in South Africa, service-learning is a part ofstate mandated transformations for higher education.

 

Smith-Paríolá, J., & Gòkè-Paríolá, A. (2006). Expanding the parameters of service learning: A case study. Journal of Studies in International Education, 10(1), 71-86.

Service learning is an increasingly significant component of academic programs on many college campuses. International studies programs and study-abroad programs are becoming important frontiers in this trend. Today, many colleges and other organizations provide students with opportunities for service learning in international settings. However, a common assumption of such programs is that students will spend at least a full semester abroad. This article examines how service learning can be effectively incorporated into short-term programs—that is, programs lasting only 2 to 3 weeks. Referencing a particular 2-week study-abroad program in Jamaica and drawing from the literature on service learning, we discuss the special challenges that confront such programs and propose strategies for successfully grappling with those challenges.

Kiely, R. (2005). A transformative learning model for service-learning: A longitudinal case study. Michigan Journal of Community Service Learning, 12(1), 5-22.

This article presents a longitudinal research study that led to the development of a theoretical framework for explaining how students experience the process of transformational learning in service-learning. The article describes nonreflective and reflective dimensions of the process of transformational learning. The author recommends that future research focus on supporting the transformative potential of service-learning.

 

Keith, N.V. (2005). Community service-learning in the face of globalization: Rethinking theory and practice. Michigan Journal of Community Service Learning, 11(2), 5-24.

Globalization is a multifaceted phenomenon that does not yield easy definitions. The author examines three of its interconnected faces—neoliberalism, time-space compression, and globalism—to trace their implications for two principles of service-learning practice:reciprocity and meeting community needs. The article reconceptualizes these two principles,concluding that interdependence is a better fit with the values and practices of the field than reciprocity; conceptions of community should emphasize difference and intersection of public and private spaces; and community needs should be defined to support citizenship action, public work, and social justice.

 

Sternberger, L. (2005). International service-learning: Integrating academics and active learning in the world. The Journal of Public Affairs, 8, 75-96.

From initial efforts in the 1960′s, service-learning in general and international service-learning in particular have assumed an increasingly prominent place in higher education. Both students and educators have recognized that such programs offer an unparalleled opportunity to integrate classroom theory with real world application and promote powerful learning and personal transformation, while responding to pressing needs within the larger global community. This essay examines the process by which international service-learning evolved from a domestic focus; describes the philosophy, learning outcomes, and components of successful international service learning programs; presents a number of model approaches and programs; and highlights current scholarship regarding the impact of international service-learning as well as potential directions for future research.

Monard-Weissman, K. (2003). Enhancing caring capacities: A case study of an international service-learning program. Journal of Higher Education Outreach and Engagement, 8(2), 41-53.

This article highlights the theoretical framework of care to describe the relationships nurtured among students and community members who were involved in the International Partnership for Service-Learning Program in Guayaquil, Ecuador. The data for this article derive from participant observation, field notes, semi-structured and informal interviews, and students’ extensive reflective writings collected during the summer of 2001. This article presents the outcomes of the program as they relate to the framework of care. These outcomes are presented in four categories: (1) building connections; (2) sharing feelings toward the cared-for; (3) being a “family”; and (4) responding to the
cared-for’s needs. These outcomes generate questions about the challenges of fostering caring relationships among diversely situated groups of individuals engaged in international service-learning experiences.

 

Zitomer, D. H., & Johnson, P. (2003). International service learning in environmental engineering. In P. Bizier & P. DeBarry (Eds.), World water & environmental resources congress 2003 and related symposia. Proceedings of the congress, June 23-26, 2003, Philadelphia, PA (pp. 1917-1924). Reston, VA: American Society of Civil Engineers.

Educational experiences that relate social and technical subjects offer students the opportunity to reflect on the broad significance of environmental engineering. Although it is often difficult to join social and technical subjects in a classroom setting, the link may be more easily made through service learning projects in which students use classroom knowledge and hands-on service to implement solutions for a given community. As an example, a senior civil and environmental engineering student project to design a sanitary sewer for an in-need community in San Benito, Guatemala, is described. Students traveled to the site, performed a land survey, and gathered other design data while also learning about Guatemalan history and culture. The students apply knowledge from required courses and the humanities/social science class “Latin American Health, Infrastructure, and Environment” to arrive at an appropriate final design. The international design project is described as an approach to increase student appreciation of the engineering profession and support educational goals, such as increased understanding of engineering solutions in a societal context, and the ability to function on a multidisciplinary team.

 

Porter, M. & Monard, K. (2001). Ayni in the global village: Building relationships of reciprocity through international service-learning. Michigan Journal of Community Service Learning, 8(1), 5-17.

Understanding and fostering reciprocity is a central aim of service-learning programs. This article highlights the indigenous Andean concept of ayni as a means of integrating reciprocity into a broader, holistic framework. This approach also stretches our understanding of interdependence along trajectories that extend well beyond a traditional Western framework. We present data drawn from a semester-long seminar and Alternative Spring Break spent building a school in highland Bolivia. Analysis from extensive student reflective writings and discussions provide personalized responses to core questions. Elements of ayni are applied to critique both the practice and pedagogy of service-learning, and to raise questions about the challenges of fostering reciprocity among diversely situated citizens of the global village.

 

Simonelli, J. (2000). Service learning abroad: Liability and logistics. Metropolitan Universities, 11(1), 35-59.

Learning, logistics, and liability are the three “l’s” which define off-campus experiential programs. For those planning these experiences, the liability component, including safety issues, legal concerns, and ethical responsibility to the communities we work in, can threaten program viability and overshadow educational objectives. A service focus increases these difficulties, and demands specialized preparation by all involved.

 

Weigart, K. (1998). Academic Service Learning: Its Meaning and Relevance. In R. Rhoads and J. Howard (Eds.), Academic Service Learning:A Pedagogy of Action and Reflection. New Directions for Teaching and Learning. 73. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.

This chapter has three purposes: to clarify what academic service learning entails; to identify some of the crucial debates in the field; and to invite faculty and administrators who are not yet familiar with it to consider its implementation. I first highlight some elements of contemporary higher education that serve as background for the growth and relevance of academic service learning, and then turn to a detailed examination of it.

Williams, D. D., & Eiserman, W. D. (1997). Expanding the dialogue: Service-learning in Costa Rica and Indonesia. Michigan Journal of Community Service Learning, 4, 90-97.

This article reviews findings from a study on service-learning in universities in Indonesia and Costa Rica. Much can be learned from other countries regarding service-learning’s role in community development and university commitment to service-learning. A new book on service-learning in higher education (Jacoby, 1996) “provides a historical overview and a context for understanding the essential linkage of service and learning; it describes the current state of practice; and it highlights the relationship between service-learning and institutional educational goals” (p. 5). Although the several authors examine predominant assumptions underlying the combining of community service and academic learning in higher education, offer several illustrative examples from colleges and universities, and explore issues related to designing and administering service-learning programs, the focus is almost exclusively on servicelearning in the United States. But, as questions are asked and plans are developed for service-learning programs, whether on individual, institutional or national levels, we can learn from the experiences of those who have been involved in the development and implementation of service-learning programs in other contexts too. Existing programs outside the United States may inform service-learning in this country. Unknown to many, some of the most comprehensive and innovative approaches to servicelearning have been designed and implemented in developing countries (Eberly & Sherraden, 1990). In the present study, the University of Costa Rica’s compulsory service-learning program, which began in 1975, is compared to a similar, even older program in Indonesia. This article explores the historical roots, program components, perceived outcomes, and strengths and weaknesses of programs in Costa Rica (the Trabajo Comunal Universitario or TCU projects) and Indonesia (the Kuliah Kerja Nyata or KKN projects).

 

Book Summaries:

Bringle, R., Hatcher, J. & Jones, S. (2011). International service learning: Conceptual frameworks and research. Sterling, VA: Stylus.

International Service Learning (ISL) borrows from the domains of service learning, study abroad, and international education to create a new pedagogy that adds new and unique value from this combination. It is a high-impact pedagogy with the potential to improve students’ academic attainment, contribute to their personal growth, and develop global civic outcomes.The international service experience provides opportunities for additional learning goals, activities, and relationships that are not available in a domestic service learning course or in a traditional study abroad course. The service experience develops reflection while shedding light on and providing an added dimension to the curricular component of the study abroad course. The international education component further broadens students’ perspectives by providing opportunities to compare and contrast North American and international perspectives on course content.

This book focuses on conducting research on ISL, which includes developing and evaluating hypotheses about ISL outcomes and measuring its impact on students, faculty, and communities. The book argues that rigorous research is essential to improving the quality of ISL’s implementation and delivery, and providing the evidence that will lead to wider support and adoption by the academy, funders, and partners. It is intended for both practitioners and scholars, providing guidance and commentary on good practice. The volume provides a pioneering analysis of and understanding of why and under what conditions ISL is an effective pedagogy.

Individual chapters discuss conceptual frameworks, research design issues, and measurement strategies related to student learning outcomes; the importance of ISL course and program design; the need for faculty development activities to familiarize faculty with the component pedagogical strategies; the need for resources and collaboration across campus units to develop institutional capacity for ISL; and the role that community constituencies should assume as co-creators of the curriculum, co-educators in the delivery of the curriculum, and co-investigators in the evaluation of and study of ISL. The contributors demonstrate sensitivity to ethical implications of ISL, to issues of power and privilege, to the integrity of partnerships, to reflection, reciprocity, and community benefits.

 

Bringle, R. G., & Tonkin, H. (2004). International service-learning: A research agenda. In H. Tonkin, S. J. Deeley, M. Pusch, D. Quiroga, M. J. Siegel, J. Whiteley, & R. G. Bringle, Service-learning across cultures: Promise and achievement (pp. 365-374). New York: International Partnership for Service-Learning and Leadership.

Service-learning links service to the community with formal academic study, for the enrichment of both, and is gaining in popularity among students and their teachers. What happens when we add the dimension of another culture and another part of the world?

This book, the culmination of a three-year, three-part study funded by the Ford Foundation, explores the effects of international service-learning on the students who participate, the institutions where they study, and the agencies where they perform their service. It tells us that international service-learning is a transforming experience for all concerned, and a means through which we can create citizens and individuals who are responsive to the needs of others, civically engaged, and prepared for a peaceful future based on the globalization of compassion, tolerance, and understanding.

The conclusions, based on sound research, provide useful advice to those initiating service-learning; those seeking to make the practice of international service-learning an ongoing commitment of their college or university; and those eager to encourage participation in study abroad programs that immerse students in the foreign culture, thereby making education abroad as rich and beneficial as possible for the students. Contributors: Humphrey Tonkin, Susan J. Deeley, Margaret Pusch, Diego Quiroga, Michael J. Siegel, John Whiteley, and Robert G. Bringle.

 

Chisholm, L. A. (2003). Partnerships for international service-learning. In B. Jacoby & Associates (Eds.), Building partnerships for service-learning (pp. 259-288). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

It is clear that service-learning has the potential to yield tremendous benefits to students, communities, and institutions of higher education. Increased student learning has been well documented. As communities gain new energy to meet their needs and greater capacity to capitalize on their assets, service-learning enables higher education to fulfill its civic responsibility. When service-learning lives up to its potential to lead colleges and universities to transform themselves into fully engaged citizens of their communities and the world, its ability to bring about positive social change is limitless.

To be successful, service-learning must be grounded in a wide range of solid, reciprocal, democratic partnerships. Building Partnerships for Service-Learning assembles leading voices in the field to bring their expertise to bear on this crucial topic. Faculty, administrators, student leaders, and community and corporate leaders will find this volume filled with vital information, exemplary models, and practical tools needed to make service-learning succeed.

Comprehensive in scope, Building Partnerships for Service-Learning includes:

  • Fundamentals and frameworks for developing sustainable partnerships
  • Assessment as a partnership-building process
  • The complex dynamics of collaboration between academic affairs and student affairs
  • Partnering with students to enhance service-learning
  • How to create campuswide infrastructure for service-learning
  • Profiles and case studies of outstanding partnerships with neighborhoods, community agencies, and K-12 schools
  • Partnerships for collaborative action research
  • Exploring the challenges and benefits of corporate and international partnerships
  • The dynamic relationship of service-learning and the civic renewal of higher education

Building Partnerships for Service-Learning is the essential guide to taking service-learning and partnerships to the next level.

 

Craft, R. J. (2002). International service learning. In M. E. Kenny, L. A. K. Simon, K. Kiley- Brabeck, & R. M. Lerner (Eds.), Learning to serve: Promoting civil society through service learning (pp. 297-313). Boston: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
Service learning, as defined by the editors, is the generation of knowledge that is of benefit to the community as a whole. This seventh volume in the Outreach Scholarship book series contributes a unique discussion of how service learning functions as a critical cornerstone of outreach scholarship. The sections and chapters of this book marshal evidence in support of the idea that undergraduate service learning, infused throughout the curriculum and coupled with outreach scholarship, is an integral means through which higher education can engage people and institutions of the communities of this nation in a manner that perpetuate civil society. The editors, through this series of models of service learning, make a powerful argument for the necessity of “engaged institutions”.
Liebowitz, D. J. (2000). TCBY in Limón, Costa Rica: Women’s studies and the (re)construction of identity in international service-learning. In B. J. Balliet & K. Heffernan (Eds.), The practice of change. Concepts and models for service-learning in women’s studies (pp. 163-176). Washington, DC: American Association for Higher Education.

This volume, seventh in the Service-Learning in the Disciplines Series, explores the important lessons women’s history and women’s studies hold for the broader service-learning community and the critical opportunity for women’s studies to reconnect with its activist past. The book includes essays with real examples of service-learning projects in women’s studies and lists an extensive bibliography of service-learning and women’s studies sources.

 

Fairbanks, R., & Foss, T. (1998). The global perspective at St Olaf: Study/service Indonesia. In J. DeVitas, R. Johns, & D. Simpson (Eds.), To serve and learn: The spirit of community in liberal education. NY: Peter Lang.
Written by faculty, staff, and students from ten exemplary programs in service-learning at selected liberal arts colleges across the country, this collection of essays addresses vital issues in liberal learning and education for community. Its focus is the creation of educational goals and strategies for developing a service curriculum and for assuring an integral role for service-learning within distinctive institutional settings. This book highlights intimate connections between theory and practice with a shared emphasis on critical/reflective inquiry, social responsibility, and empowerment.
Dissertation Abstracts
Hartman, E. (2008). Educating for global citizenship through service-learning: A theoretical account and curricular evaluation. Dissertation. Available at: etd.library.pitt.edu.

The last decade has witnessed substantial increases in US university study abroad programming. Related, there has been a demonstrable spike in university administrators and faculty members suggesting that their institutions prepare students for global citizenship. Yet few institutions have offered a clear conceptualization of what global citizenship is, how they educate for it, or how they measure their progress in that effort. This dissertation addresses the relative dearth of applicable theoretical constructs by offering one such construct, suggesting the specific educative process by which it may be encouraged, and discussing initial efforts evaluating its success. Its three primary contributions are: (1) a particular articulation of global citizenship that draws on existing theoretical approaches while insisting on integration with or development of strong mechanisms for application, (2) clarification of the educative process by which that articulation and practice of global citizenship may be encouraged, and (3) the development and testing of a quantitative instrument for better understanding and evaluating global citizenship and civic engagement. A pre- and post- survey is employed to develop an index of global civic engagement and awareness measures among students (1) not participating in global service-learning, (2) participating in global service-learning without a deliberate global citizenship education component, and (3) participating in global service-learning with clear attention to the integration of a global citizenship curriculum. The findings, buttressed by analysis of related qualitative data, suggest that integration of a carefully developed and articulated theoretical and practical approach to global citizenship education is essential if universities are to be successful in their efforts to create global citizens. Perhaps less intuitive and more alarming, the findings indicate that exposure to study abroad programming absent deliberate global citizenship education efforts may serve to merely reinforce stereotypes, create situations where severe cultural shock and withdrawal are likely experiences, and otherwise serve to cause young US citizens to shrink from rather than engage with the world. Taken as a whole, the analysis suggests the outcomes of many efforts to globalize campuses and create global citizens are unclear at best and that clearer conceptualizations, educative processes, and evaluation efforts are needed.